Council

Council

info@hamiltoncatch.org

July 13/05 Report
Scheduled start time: 2:15 pm Actual start time: 2:25 pm Adjournment: 2:53 pm

Present:

Pearson,
Samson,
McCarthy,
Bratina,
McHattie,
Collins,
Merulla,
Whitehead,
Kelly,
Jackson (out 1x for 1 minute),
Morelli (arrived 2:29 pm ).

Absent:

Braden,
Bruckler,
Di Ianni,
Ferguson,
Mitchell.

No media present.

CATCH: Don

Acting Mayor Bob Bratina : "Good afternoon everyone. I'd like to call this meeting of City Council to order and ask everyone to stand for the national anthem." O Canada "Mr. Clerk are there are changes to the agenda?"

Christenson : "Yes, thank you Mr. Deputy Mayor, we have an added council communication item 5.4 which is a petition from the residents of Pleasant Valley respecting the zoning amendment application ZAC-05-50 and draft plan application submitted to the City of Hamilton to develop the former Pleasant Valley School site in Dundas. The recommendation for this correspondence is that it be received and referred to the General Manager of Planning and Development for a report to the Planning and Economic Development Committee. As well we have two added licensing committee reports noted as items 6.4 and 6.5."

[Note: The petition objects to a proposed subdivision of 30 single family homes saying that it "exceeds a reasonable density as it is not in harmony with the established neighbourhood" and "the height of the homes should be restricted to a single storey to ensure integration with the established community and address privacy and aesthetic concerns". It also expresses concerns about accessible greenspaces, the plan to make the subdivision a gated community, safety from traffic, and limited public infrastructure such as sewer overflow and electrical service and drainage. The petition has been signed by over 300 residents]

Bratina : "Thank you. Members of Council do we have any declarations of interest? Seeing none, members of council may I have a verbal motion to approve the minutes of the City Council meeting held on June 29, 2005.
http://www.city.hamilton.on.ca/clerk/agendas-minutes-reports/
council/2005/Jun29/Minutes.pdf
Moved by councillor Pearson, seconded by councillor Kelly. All in favour? That's carried. I'd like to call on the general manager of planning and economic development to provide an update on the matter which was tabled at the last council respecting application for a modification in zoning for the property located at 675 Strathearne Avenue . And you will recall that it was tabled for two weeks by council. Councillor Merulla?

Merulla : "Thank you Mr Deputy Mayor. Just with respect to this issue, Larry Di Ianni, Mayor Di Ianni, had requested that it be deferred to Monday, July 18 so that he could be present for the meeting, so I'm putting forward a motion. I think it would probably be more appropriate to do that rather than go through the presentation today, wait until July 18th."

Bratina : "So moved by councillor Merulla, seconded by councillor McHattie. All in favour of holding that off? Thank you. That's carried. In communications, councillor Collins, can I have a motion on communications. I'm sorry, councillor Whitehead."

Whitehead : "Yeah, could I just, on this added item, I guess it's 5.5? The Pleasantview Valley ? Can I just provide direction for staff that when the zoning application comes forward to Planning and Economic Development Committee that that meeting, in fact I want to make that clear as a matter of record so the clerk can record it, that the meeting take place in Dundas. [discussion off-mic]" Bratina : "Are we okay with that? Can we move on now to communications? Councillor Collins may I have a motion on the communications?" Collins : "Mr Chairman it's moved by myself and seconded by councillor Jackson that council communications 5.1 to 5.5 be approved as follows and it's before all members of council. [pause: off-mic discussion?] Bratina : "Alright, on 5.1, correspondence from the Chairs of Sanford Healthy Community Development Committee respecting the impact on the Norman Pinky Lewis Recreation Centre upon closure of Sanford Avenue School.
http://www.city.hamilton.on.ca/clerk/agendas-minutes-reports/
council/2005/Jul13/5_1.pdf
And how shall we deal with that Mr. Clerk?" Christenson : "Through you Mr. Deputy-Mayor, you may want to refer this to the General Manager of Public Health and Social Services for a report back." Bratina : "Alright, moved by councillor Collins, seconded by councillor Jackson. All in favour of that recommendation? That's carried. And the correspondence from Joe Rinaldo, General Manager of Finance and Corporate Services respecting compliance audit update?
http://www.city.hamilton.on.ca/clerk/agendas-minutes-reports/
council/2005/Jul13/5_2.pdf
The recommendation is that it be received. Moved by councillor Pearson, seconded by councillor McCarthy, all in favour? That's carried. The correspondence from Allen Whyperle, the president of the Hamilton Law Association respecting unsafe conditions at the John Sopinka Courthouse, 45 Main Street East in Hamilton.
http://www.city.hamilton.on.ca/clerk/agendas-minutes-reports/
council/2005/Jul13/5_3.pdf
The recommendation is that it be received and referred to the General Manager of Public Works for a report to the Public Works, Infrastructure and Environment Committee. Moved by councillor Morelli, seconded by councillor Whitehead. All in favour of that? That's carried. And next we have committee reports. And councillor Collins can I have a motion to move in Committee of the Whole for consideration of those committee reports?" Collins : "Mr Deputy-Mayor, moved by myself, seconded by councillor Jackson that council move into Committee of the Whole for consideration of the committee reports." Bratina : "And that is moved, seconded and carried. Alright, the Planning and Economic Development Committee.
http://www.city.hamilton.on.ca/clerk/agendas-minutes-reports/
Planning-Economic-Development/2005/Jul05/Report%2005-016.pdf
Members of council, the Planning and Economic Development Committee presents its 16th report and respectfully recommends item #1, item #2, item #3. [items 1 to 10 are carried]. On item #11, councillor McCarthy?"

[11. Application for a Change in Zoning for Lands known as Part of Lot 23, Concession 3 (Flamborough) (PED05046) (Ward 15) (Item 6.3) That approval be given to Zoning Application ZAR-05-37, Coreslab International, owner , for a change in zoning from "M1" (Prestige Industrial) Zone to "M2" (General Industrial) Zone (Blocks "1" and "3"), and from "M2" (General Industrial) Zone to "M1" (Prestige Industrial) Zone (Block "2"), to permit a boundary adjustment to follow the centreline of Pyramid Way and the existing property boundaries, for lands known as Part of Lot 23, Concession 3, Coreslab Drive, shown as Blocks "1", "2" and "3", on Appendix "A" to Report PED05046, on the following basis: (a) That Blocks "1" and "3 be rezoned from the "M1" (Prestige Industrial) Zone to the "M2" (General Industrial) Zone; (b) That Block "2" be rezoned from the "M2" (General Industrial) Zone to the "M1" (Prestige Industrial) Zone; (c) That the Draft By-law, attached as Appendix "C" to Report No. PED05046, which has been prepared in a form satisfactory to Corporate Counsel, be enacted by City Council; and, (d) That the proposed changes in zoning are in conformity with the Hamilton-Wentworth Official Plan and the Town of Flamborough Official Plan .]

McCarthy : "Thank you Mr. Chairman. Through you to planning staff, this issue is to deal with the zoning application for Coreslab in Flamborough in Clappison's Corners prestige industrial area. It's my understanding that it has no bearing whatsoever to the application that's come before me, or coming before council for an expansion of a new manufacturing facility. Actually they say expansion, but actually it's a new manufacturing facility on the northerly part of Coreslab land holdings. I just wanted to get confirmation that this is true. I was told that this is a housekeeping item. The one that was passed by the planning staff regarding that application, on item 11, and I just wanted to confirm that there's no bearing whatsoever." Coveyduck : "That is correct. This is a housekeeping amendment. If you look at the location as attached to the report, it does show that there's small little triangles inappropriately zoned. When the road went through they weren't appropriately zoned and what we're trying to do here is just clean that up." McCarthy : "Is it fair to say that if we didn't clean it up they wouldn't be able to proceed with the application that's going to come before council?" Coveyduck : "I actually don't have an answer for that. I would have to look at that and see if there's an impact. If there's an application coming before council on another item, in any event if there was an issue we'd clean it up as part of that. What this is doing is just looking at this from a housekeeping perspective, which we would have done in any event whether there was another application or not." McCarthy : "Okay, thank you very much." Bratina : "So on item 11? That's carried. Item 12? . Item 17? [all carried]. I'm sorry, item 18, councillor Whitehead.?"

Whitehead : "Yes, actually going back, I have an amendment for 14. Coming forward not a motion but it's an amendment."

[14. Application for a Modification in Zoning for Lands Located at 264 Concession Street (Hamilton) (PED05045) (Ward 7) (Item 6.6) That Zoning Application ZAR-05-32, Imre Szilvassy, applicant, for a modification to the current "E-2" (Multiple Dwellings) District, to permit the ground floor of the existing dwelling to be used for a doctor's office, for lands located at 264 Concession Street, as shown on Appendix "A" to Report PED05045, be approved on the following basis: (a) That the subject lands be rezoned from "E-2" (Multiple Dwellings) District to "E-2" - 'H' (Multiple Dwellings - Holding) District, Modified. (b) That the Draft By-law, which has been prepared in a form satisfactory to Corporate Counsel, be enacted by City Council. (c) That the amending By-law apply the Holding provisions of Section 36 (1) of the Planning Act, R.S.O., 1990, to the subject lands by introducing the Holding symbol 'H' as a suffix to the proposed Zoning District. The Holding provision will prohibit the development of the subject lands until such time as the following has been completed: (i) That the applicant has received approval of a Site Plan Control Application, to the satisfaction of the Manager, Development Planning; City Council may remove the 'H' symbol and, thereby, give effect to the "E-2" District, Modified, provisions, by enactment of an amending By-law once the condition is fulfilled; (d) That the proposed change in zoning is in conformity with the Official Plan for the Hamilton Planning Area; and, (e) That upon satisfying the conditions of the 'H' symbol and submitting the required fee, the Director of Development and Real Estate, Planning and Development Department, be authorized and directed to give the prescribed notice in accordance with the provisions of the Planning Act and to prepare a By-law, in a form satisfactory to Corporate Counsel, to remove the 'H' symbol for presentation to City Council.]

Whitehead : "It's moved by myself and seconded by councillor Kelly the application for modification of zoning for lands located at 264 Concession Street, item 14 of Planning and Economic Development Committee report 05-016 be revised by the deletion of section (b) to (e) inclusive and their replacement with the following: that the draft bylaw which has been prepared in a form satisfactory to corporate counsel not be forwarded to city council for enactment until such time as the applicant has received approval of the site plan control application to the satisfaction of the Manager of Development Planning, and (c) that the proposed changed rezoning is in conformity with the Official Plan and for the Hamilton planning area. Moved and seconded." Bratina : "Any comments? All in favour of that motion? Carried. Alright Mr Clerk I believe we were up to item 16. No we were 18. 17's done. Item 18? Item 19? Item 20? Item 21? I'm sorry, councillor Samson? [someone speaking off-mic]. Item 21? We're all in favour of that? Okay, that's carried. And councillor Samson?"

Samson : "For the information section (m), it's talking about Ainslie Wood. And the last paragraph talks about a letter from the Royal Botanical Gardens, and it talks about Churchill Park , and it talks about through the regular development application process. Can I just have an explanation of what we're talking about there? It seems to me a couple of council meetings ago we had a notice of motion with regard to Churchill Park , Royal Botanical Gardens and so forth?" Bratina : "Councillor McHattie?" McHattie : "I think the idea here is RBG with their current financial issues would like to have the opportunity to develop a part of Churchill Park . And they had asked for a deferral of the Ainslie Wood Westdale Secondary Plan, because the plan identifies Churchill Park as open space, you know the park. So we, and they've been part of the process. It's been about a three year process to develop the secondary plan. They came in with a deferral request just in the last couple of weeks. So we don't feel that's appropriate, so we went ahead at committee and passed the secondary plan. But should the RBG wish to bring forward a development application for Churchill Park , they can do so, and they just go through the regular planning process and seek a change to the Official Plan, a change to the zoning, and that sort of thing. Of course, I don't support that. That was what the motion was you were referring to councillor Samson at a previous council meeting, but they have that right under the Planning Act." Bratina : "Councillor?" Samson : "So in other words they'd have to get the zoning changed from open space which is what it currently is now, and that went through and would be open space to R-1 or whatever they wanted, R-2 or". McHattie : "Just to clarify for anyone who's watching. Churchill Park will remain a park. It will remain open space. And should RBG wish to change that, they can come to us and they're involved in the planning process to proceed at." Bratina : "But that's not to say that's likely going to happen. As far as the residents are concerned now, Churchill Park is a park and that's how we would like to see it." McHattie : "That's our perspective here."

Bratina : "Alright, may I have a, councillor Whitehead, may I have a motion on the report?" Whitehead : "Thank you. Moved by myself, seconded by councillor Pearson that the 16th report of the Planning and Economic Development Committee be adopted and the information section received." Bratina : "All in favour? That's carried. And now we move on and Committee of the Whole presents it's 10th report and respectfully recommends item #1? And Councillor Merulla."

Merulla : "Yes Mr Deputy Mayor, if I could just have an opportunity to appoint, or nominate, Terry Whitehead, councillor Whitehead to the actual committee responsible for accessible transit services?" Bratina : "Moved by councillor Merulla, seconded by councillor Collins. Is that acceptable to you, councillor Whitehead? Yes? All in favour of that motion? That's carried. So item number 1 is carried. Item #2? And those are the only two items and any further discussion? Councillor Collins can I have a motion on the report?" Collins : "Mr Chairman it's moved by myself and seconded by councillor Jackson that the 10th report of Committee of the Whole be adopted and the information section received." Bratina : "All in favour of that? Carried. Members of council the Committee of the Whole presents its 11th report, and I don't have that report in front of me right now. Where did it go? Oh yes. This is on the yellow sheet that was just added by the clerks. And respectfully recommends item #1, item #2, . item #26 [all carried]. And councillor Collins, may I have a motion on the report?" Collins : "Mr Chairman, it's moved by myself and seconded by councillor Jackson that the 11th report of the Committee of the Whole be adopted and the information section received." Bratina : "All in favour of that? That's carried. Now members of council, the Licensing Committee presents it's fifth report, and once again Madame Clerk I don't have that. Sorry. And respectfully recommends item #1, #2, #3, #4 [all carried]. And councillor Merulla may I have a motion on that report?" Merulla : "Mr Chairman, moved by myself and seconded by councillor McHattie that the fifth report of the Licensing Committee be adopted and the information section received." Bratbina: "All in favour? That's carried. Members of council the Licensing Committee presents its sixth report and respectfully recommends item #1. [carried] And that's all the items on that report. Councillor Merulla may I have a motion?" Merulla : "Thank you Mr. Chairman. Moved by myself, seconded by councillor Morelli that the sixth report of the Licensing Committee be adopted and the information section received." Bratina : "All in favour? That is carried. On to motions now. 7.1 operational review of licencing and property. I'm sorry? Uh. Councillor Merulla?"

Merulla : "Yes, Mr Chairman, my apologies. Under licensing, I didn't amend some wording with respect to the Da Night Tavern. It makes reference to the Heritage Cycling Club, and the fact that they were being represented by them. We've been corrected. That was mentioned at the meeting, but apparently the Heritage Cycling Club did not represent the Da Nite Tavern, so if we could omit that in its entirety, it would be greatly appreciated." Bratina : "So moved to make that amendment, deleting the reference to the Heritage cycling? Seconded by councillor Whitehead. All in favour of that? [carried] And on the motion? Moved by Merulla, seconded by Whitehead. All in favour? Carried. Item 7.2 on motions is funding mechanisms to support rural and agricultural development issues. [voices off-mic] Oh, I'm sorry. Ah, okay. This is operational review of licensing and property standards. Sorry I confused your last number with this one, councillor. Do you have a motion?" Merulla : "I do indeed, and I believe the first . inadvertently picked it up. Okay, thank you very much. Moved by myself and seconded by councillor McHattie that an operational review of licensing and property standards division be conducted and that the City Manager be directed to initiate an internal operational review of the licensing and property standards division." Bratina : "Comments on that motion? Councillor Jackson."

Jackson : "Mr Deputy Mayor, I strongly support this initiative. And I just ask either the mover or the City Manager what will roughly be the time frame of conducting this operational review, and I would fully expect, I guess, the report be brought back to this committee of the whole. Mr Deputy-Mayor, through you to Glen Peace, please." Peace : "Through you Deputy-Mayor to the councillor. I'm not in a position to give you a time frame, but I will consult with staff. We're going to do it internally, and I will report back and of course it will come back to council." Jackson : "I'm assuming that the first report back will be in the fall sometime?" Peace : "I'll report back early fall with a time frame for the review." Jackson : "Thank you Glen. Thank you Mr Deputy Mayor." Bratina : "Any further comments? All in favour of that motion? That's carried. Now to 7.2, funding mechanisms to support rural and agricultural development issues. This is a motion of councillor Mitchell. It will be moved by councillor Pearson? Seconded by councillor Merulla? All in favour? That is carried."

[7.2 Funding Mechanisms to Support Rural and Agricultural Development Issues (Pearson/Merulla) Whereas the level of investment to support rural and agricultural communities and to support the development of a more competitive rural economy cannot be reasonably sustained by the current property tax yield. Therefore be it resolved: (a) That the Council of the City of Hamilton endorses the resolution of the Ontario Mayors for the Future of Agriculture recommending that the Province of Ontario immediately develop effective funding mechanisms specifically to support rural and agricultural development issues. (b) And further, that all Ontario Municipal communities endorse this recommendation through their respective Councils and respond back to the Ontario Mayors for the Future of Agriculture, c/o Mayor Rita Kalmbach, Norfolk County .]

Bratina : "Item number 7.3, request for proposal for the sale of municipal property identified as 171 Main Street East . Councillor Kelly?" Kelly : "Yes, Mr. Chairman, moved by myself, seconded by councillor Tom Jackson, that item 21 of the Planning and Ec-Dev Report 04-014 respecting the RFP for the sale and development of 171 Main Street East be lifted from the table. And members have it in front of them." Bratina : "All right. Any comment? That's seconded." Kelly : "That's seconded by councillor Jackson." Bratina : "I'm sorry, that's seconded already. Councillor McHattie, did you have a comment?" McHattie : "I just wanted to get clarification on the issue. What's involved?" Kelly : "This motion, Mr Chairman, will lift it from the table, and the next one we can get into an explanation of it." Bratina : "All right. So all in favour of that? Carried. And now councillor Kelly would you speak to the main motion."

Kelly : "Yeah, item 7.3 (b) Mr Chairman is moved by myself, seconded by councillor Jackson, that item 21 of the Planning and Ec-Dev Committee 04-014 respecting the RFP for the sale and development of municipal property identified as 171 Main Street East be approved. And to go back to that item, item 16 of the Committee of the Whole report approved by council dealing with the request for proposal for the sale and development of the city-owned lands under contract C2-11-02-B municipally known as 171 Main Street East Hamilton be rescinded and that the bid security be returned to the proponent. And item (b) that the city-owned lands known municipally as 171 Main Street East, Hamilton, be maintained within the city inventory of property and continue to be utilized for public parking, pending the outcome of the downtown zoning and parking bylaw currently underway. Mr Chairman, essentially what this is is that we had initially declared this as surplus property initiative and issued an RFP for it, and upon reconsideration by council we decided that with some of the activity going on downtown, especially around Ferguson and some areas, that we want to maintain this as a city parking lot, pending the overall review of parking through the downtown. So we've rescinded the RFP; given back the bid money to the proponent; and simply said we're going to hang onto the property." Bratina . "Alright. Yes, councillor McHattie?"

McHattie : "Can I just ask through you Mr Chair to councillor Kelly, what was the use that had been proposed by the person who put the bid in?" Kelly : "Actually if I could, Mr Chairman, I'd defer to Mr. Marini who's department's been looking after this problem." Ron Marini : "Mr Mayor, the situation was that it was declared surplus, and in the course of the downtown secondary plan they had put in a proposal which was a multi-use structure - an apartment building with commercial. And what had happened was the . successful bidder, council directed us to negotiate the requisite agreement of purchase and sale. And what had happened was they'd tried to change the terms of the RFP and different conditions, and couldn't reach a concordance, and there was legal advice that we should be terminating this negotiation, that they were changing from what had been an original RFP process." Bratina : "Councillor McHattie? Councillor Whitehead." [ 23:42 ]

Whitehead : "Then is it safe to assume, through the Chair to Ron, that this motion was under your carriage and you brought it forth?" Marini : "What happened was it started through planning, and we did a report through planning committee last August and it had been deferred at the council table because the proponent didn't feel there was additional information there to pursue. And we did pursue that additional information with the city solicitor and come back to, as a result of those discussions, that there's no new information. It's simply the same situation and we can't recommend that we move forward with this." Whitehead : "I'm not sure if that answers my question." Marini : "The answer was that, yes this started with downtown renewal, with participation from real estate. So I brought the report forward as an RFP with a recommendation to council, and council directed real estate to negotiate the sale and purchase." Whitehead : "Okay, but the question specific to the motion in front of us is it drafted by yourself?" Marini : "It's drafted by the city solicitor's office." Whitehead : "Okay, thank you. That's fine." Bratina : "Okay, any further comments on that? If I can be of help it's the property just to the west of the Shakespeare Restaurant on the north side of the street, which most of you know as a municipal parking lot. So, moved by councillor Kelly, seconded by councillor Jackson. All in favour? That's carried."

[7.3(a) Request for Proposal for the Sale and Development of Municipal Property Identified as 171 Main Street East (PD03085a) (Kelly/Jackson) That Item 21 of Planning and Economic Development Committee Report 04-014 respecting Request for Proposal for the Sale and Development of Municipal Property Identified as 171 Main Street East (PD03085a) be lifted from the table. 21. Request For Proposal for the Sale and Development of Municipal Property Identified as 171 Main Street East (PD03085(a)) (Ward 2) (Item 8.2) (a) That Item 16 of the Committee of the Whole Report 03-016, approved by Council on June 11, 2003, dealing with the Request for Proposal (RFP) for the Sale and Development of the City-owned lands under Contract C2-11-02-B, municipally known as 171 Main Street East, Hamilton, be rescinded, and that the bid security be returned to the proponent. (b) That the City-owned lands known municipally as 171 Main Street East, Hamilton, be maintained within the Municipal Inventory of Property and continue to be utilized for public parking pending the outcome of the Downtown Parking/Zoning By-law Study, currently underway.

7.3(b) Request for Proposal for the Sale and Development of Municipal Property Identified as 171 Main Street East (PD03085a) (Kelly/Jackson) That Item 21 of Planning and Economic Development Committee Report 04-014 respecting Request for Proposal for the Sale and Development of Municipal Property Identified as 171 Main Street East (PD03085a) be approved as follows: 21. Request For Proposal for the Sale and Development of Municipal Property Identified as 171 Main Street East (PD03085(a)) (Ward 2) (Item 8.2) (a) That Item 16 of the Committee of the Whole Report 03-016, approved by Council on June 11, 2003, dealing with the Request for Proposal (RFP) for the Sale and Development of the City-owned lands under Contract C2-11-02-B, municipally known as 171 Main Street East, Hamilton, be rescinded, and that the bid security be returned to the proponent. (b) That the City-owned lands known municipally as 171 Main Street East, Hamilton, be maintained within the Municipal Inventory of Property and continue to be utilized for public parking pending the outcome of the Downtown Parking/Zoning By-law Study, currently underway.]

Bratina : "Item number 7.4. Do we have a motion? We don't have an item 7.4. There was possibly going to be an item 7.4. [comments off-mic]. Anybody want to take this advantage to use 7.4? [laughter]. Members of Council are there any motions? Councillors Collins." Collins : "Mr Chair I'd like to nominate councillor Whitehead to the transit/gas tax funding subcommittee we had just established a couple of weeks ago, if I can have a seconder for that." Bratina : "Seconded by councillor McHattie. All in favour? That's carried. Councillor Merulla."

Merulla : "Thank you Mr Chairman. Just with respect to Riverdale Community Centre which is located actually in ward five. Councillor Collins went through an extensive consultation in renaming Riverdale Community Centre, and in doing so had the significant majority of his residents concur with our initiative to name it the Dominic Agostino Community Centre. So if I could have the opportunity to refer this motion to the Naming Committee, it would be greatly appreciated." Bratina : "Seconded by councillor Kelly. All in favour of that? That's carried. Members of council are there any notices of motion? Members of council is there any information you wish to convey to the general public? And, seeing, councillor Jackson? Anything you'd like to convey to the general public? [answer off-mic] Okay. Councillor Collins, may I have a motion on the bylaws."

Collins : "Mr chairman it's moved by myself, seconded by councillor Jackson that those numbers 05-198 to 05-220, attached here be passed, that the corporate seal be fixed thereto and the bylaws signed by the mayor and the city clerk and numbered as 05-198 to 05-220." Bratina : "All in favour? Carried. Mr Clerk." Christenson : "There was a, based on council tabling one of the items that we had before us today, those numbers will only go to bylaw number 219 and we need to go through them individually." Collins : "Moved as amended." Bratina : "Moved as amended? And seconded? And all in favour? Carried. [discussion off-mic including deputy mayor Bratina] Just the numbers. Okay, here we go. Bylaw number 05-198? 05-199? . 05-219? [after each councillors are heard to say 'carried']. That's all carried. And all I need now is a motion to adjourn. Moved by Merulla, seconded by Kelly. All in favour? Carried. Thank you very much." [28:34]